With so many outstanding shotguns on the market, choosing the best one can feel overwhelming. That’s why we’ve created this Shotgun Comparison Guide—to give you a clear, side-by-side look at the top-selling shotguns based on performance, reliability, purpose, and value.

🔥 Top Shotguns Compared

Model Type Gauge Best For Notable Features MSRP
Mossberg 500 Pump-Action 12/20 Versatile Use Dual extractors, ambidextrous safety ~$450
Remington 870 Pump-Action 12/20 Home Defense Proven reliability, wide aftermarket parts ~$500
Benelli M4 Semi-Auto 12 Tactical Use Gas-operated, used by U.S. military ~$1,900
Beretta A300 Ultima Semi-Auto 12/20 Hunting/Sporting Soft recoil, fast cycling ~$1,000
Stoeger M3000 Semi-Auto 12 Waterfowl Hunting Inertia-driven, affordable quality ~$650
Mossberg 590 Shockwave Pump 12 Home Defense Compact, legal without NFA tax stamp ~$500
CZ Drake Over/Under 12/20 Trap/Skeet Traditional styling, excellent balance ~$700
Winchester SXP Defender Pump 12 Tactical/Home Rotary bolt, inertia-assisted slide ~$400
Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 Semi-Auto 12 Premium Hunting Carbon fiber rib, Comfortech recoil system ~$2,000

🧠 What to Consider When Comparing Shotguns

  • Purpose: Home defense, hunting, sport shooting

  • Action Type: Pump vs. semi-auto vs. over/under

  • Budget: Do you want entry-level or high-end performance?

  • Gauge: 12 gauge is most versatile; 20 gauge for lighter recoil

  • Recoil & Comfort: Choose recoil-absorbing stocks or gas systems if sensitive

✅ Our Recommendation

  • Best for Beginners: Mossberg 500 or Remington 870

  • Best Tactical Option: Benelli M4 or Mossberg 590 Shockwave

  • Best Value for Hunters: Stoeger M3000

  • Premium Performance: Benelli Super Black Eagle 3

At MegaShotgun.com, we only stock top-rated, high-demand shotguns trusted by professionals, enthusiasts, and first-time buyers. Need help deciding? Reach out to our team and we’ll walk you through it.